Drawing by Kristina, age 7
A Major Social Problem
Although children have been sexually abused by adults for centuries, it
is only in the last decade or so that child sexual abuse has been exposed
as the enormous social problem it is. In the early eighties, many women
who experienced sexual abuse as children began to break the silence and
reveal the terrible secrets they had long kept hidden. In sharing their
painful stories, these brave survivors forced society to face the disturbing
truth: that too many children lose their childhood to sexual abuse and
too many adults carry deep and lasting scars because of it. 1
Since then, the number of adults and children disclosing abuse has climbed
rapidly. More and more people have begun to seek help to heal from the
trauma. Most have come forward after years of silence because they were
unable to reveal the abuse while it was occurring. Gradually the myths
and distortions about the sexual exploitation of children are being stripped
away and we are learning just how many lives are affected by it.
A growing body of research has contributed to more accurate information
about the nature and extent of child sexual abuse in Canada. However, there
are still no national statistics on the sexual victimization of children
and there are still significant gaps in the knowledge base in this field.
In 1980 the federal government established a committee to study sexual
offenses against children and youth. In 1984 the Badgley Report estimated
alarmingly high levels of child sexual abuse. In a random survey of adults,
one-third of males and one-half of females said they had been the victims
of at least one unwanted sexual act. Four out of five of these acts had
occurred in childhood. Most of them were never reported to authorities.2
The majority of the population has been touched
by sexual abuse
through family and friends. It makes
people sick, yet offenders
deny and minimize. It's ugly, revolting
to think that adults use
children for sexual pleasure, would intentionally
hurt children
and not understand the trauma being inflicted.
Louise Ward, social worker, Family Focus
The report was deeply critical of existing responses to abuse victims
and their families, and urged major reforms to the criminal justice system.
It called for new definitions of sexual offenses as well as changes to
the rules of evidence and procedure which would give children the same
protection as adults under the law.
About the same time as the Badgley Report came out, child protection
agencies across Canada began to report and verify increasing numbers of
child sexual abuse cases. The rates of reported child sexual abuse have
risen five-fold since the late 1970's. 3
The needs of victims and survivors have exceeded the capacity of most front-line
systems to meet them. In the span of a few years, however, there has been
a revolution in public awareness and professionals from many different
disciplines have mobilized to tackle the problem.
Since the mid-eighties, a range of new government and community based
initiatives have been introduced, including new funding programs, research
and resource materials, interdisciplinary projects and protocols and changes
to provincial and territorial child protection legislation. There was also
an increase in funding for front-line services, and an expansion in programs
filling critical gaps as well as public awareness programs, child-centred
prevention programs and staff training. Unfortunately, many of these initiatives
have been reduced or eliminated by cutbacks in the 1990's.
In 1988 the federal government announced Bill C-15 which contained important
reforms to the Criminal Code of Canada and the Canada Evidence
Act. It created new offenses and expanded opportunities for courts
to receive children's testimony, thus making it easier to prosecute individuals
who sexually abuse children. In 1990, the federal government released Reaching
for Solutions, a report outlining a national strategy for dealing with
the sexual abuse of children. The report concluded that while the advances
made in combating child sexual abuse were heartening, an urgent need remained
for concerted action to respond to an ever growing number of complex and
demanding cases.
The incidence of child sexual abuse is widespread,
although still
largely hidden, and the problem permeates
every segment of
our society and all communities. Rix
Rogers
In 1993 the Canadian Panel on Violence Against Women published a report
entitled Changing the Landscape: Ending Violence - Achieving Equality.
It
contained the results of an in-depth survey which revealed startling statistics
about the sexual abuse of girls. More than half the women surveyed had
experienced some form of unwanted or intrusive sexual experience before
the age of 16. 4 One
in four said the acts involved forced or attempted forced intercourse.
Seventeen per cent reported at least one experience of incest and 34% had
been sexually abused by a non-relative before age 16. Almost half reported
one experience of incest and/or extrafamilial sexual abuse before age 16.
Ninety-six per cent of the perpetrators were men. 5
Who Are The Victims
Child sexual abuse respects no boundaries. Victims come from all
social, ethnic and economic groups. It is now estimated that as many as
one in three girls and one in five boys will experience some form of sexual
abuse before the age of 18. While every child is at risk, some groups of
children are more vulnerable than others. For example, children with disabilities
are two to ten times more likely to be abused. 6
Recent evidence suggests that more boys are victims of abuse than previously
thought. It appears that male victims are molested more often by perpetrators
outside of the family. 7
For a variety of reasons, it may be harder for males to disclose abuse.
Boys may fear being considered homosexual, since their abusers are mostly
men. They are also socialized to expect that sexual experiences are a normal
part of boys' lives and may feel social pressure not to express helplessness
or vulnerability
One factor that contributes to sexual abuse is the social isolation
of families which lack ties to and support from the community around them.
Social and geographic isolation may reduce the likelihood that abuse will
be discovered by outsiders, thus allowing it to continue.8
Social isolation may be imposed by the surrounding community when it segregates
certain less I/ acceptable" groups within it. Abusers may also enforce
the isolation of family members in an effort to maintain control over them
and preserve secrecy. Often abusers jealously watch the social contacts
of victims and profoundly curtail their social lives.
9
Multi-victim Cases
The number of cases involving multiple victims has skyrocketed in the 1980's.
Many professionals are now approaching child sexual abuse from a new perspective.
Instead of focusing solely on the number and type of incidents experienced
by each victim, they are now also looking at the number of children victimized
by any given offender.
A landmark study conducted in British Columbia looked at 30 cases between
1985 and 1989 in which numerous victims were abused by one offender. The
research found that offenders spent an average of 9.7 years victimizing
children and estimated that there were 2,099 possible sexual abuse victims,
or an average of 70 victims for each case. In 50% of the cases, the majority
of victims were male. This is in contrast to single incident investigations
in which 85% of victims are female. The majority (57%) were under 12 years
of age. Two-thirds of the children had adjustment problems prior to the
abuse. Many came from troubled families and had learning or behavioral
disorders, handicaps, communication deficits and/or a history of physical
or sexual abuse.
Child sexual abuse is a crime that generally
goes unreported,
undetected and undisclosed. Judy
Steed
Most of the offenders were in highly visible positions of trust, both
professional and non-professional. Many provided services and activities
of interest to children and their families, thereby gaining access and
providing camouflage for the abuse. They were baby-sitters, recreation
leaders, ministers, dentists and child care workers. In 63% of the cases,
the offenders had been suspected of abusing children for more than a year
prior to being investigated. They used verbal intimidation, coercion or
reinforcement as methods to control and manipulate children. In 87% of
cases, the form of abuse included physical touching, fondling or pressuring
of victims' bodies. Slightly less than half of cases included oral-genital
contact and about a third involved anal or vaginal penetration.10
What Forms Does The Abuse Take?
Sexual abuse can range from exhibitionism to intercourse, often
progressing through nudity, observing the child undressing or bathing,
fondling, mutual masturbation, oral sex and penetration of the anus and
vagina. 11 Physical
or genital contact is not necessary for abuse to have occurred. Neither
is the use of force. The exploitation of children through pornography and
prostitution are other forms of sexual abuse.
Who Is Responsible For Child Sexual Abuse?
People who sexually abuse children are accountable for their actions,
regardless of their own past abuse or the circumstances under which the
act took place. Even in cases where they may appear to have cooperated
with their abuser, children are never responsible for their abuse. Children
are at the mercy of those who have power over them and are often drawn
into abusive situations without understanding what is happening.
While a child may appear to voluntarily take part in sexual activity
or appear to initiate sexual contact with an adult, this cannot be seen
as consent by virtue of the inherent inequality between adults and children.
As Dr. Gene Abel puts it, 'Saying yes means nothing if NO is not one of
your choices." Jan Hindman affirms: 'By virtue of being a child, no is
not an option, making any form of yes meaningless." 12
Saying yes means nothing if NO is not one
of your choices.
Dr. Gene Abel
How Is Child Sexual Abuse Dealt With By The Authorities?
Every province and territory has a child welfare law which requires
that suspected cases of child abuse or neglect be reported and investigated.
Child protection officials are mandated to investigate reports and must
act promptly. Child sexual abuse is also a criminal act. It is becoming
standard practice for the police to conduct a detailed and thorough investigation
in every case where a criminal offence may have been committed. In some
jurisdictions the police have the authority to lay charges while in others,
they seek the advice of Crown counsel before doing so. Thus, the child
protection official, the police and the Crown Attorney are the three professionals
who figure most prominently in an investigation of child sexual abuse.
The roles of these individuals have changed considerably in recent years.
Since the 1988 amendments to the Criminal Code of Canada, complaints
have been more thoroughly dealt with and children have had more direct
access to the courtroom. In the past, sexual abuse cases were often treated
more as evidence of family dysfunction requiring mental health interventions
than as crimes requiring a criminal justice response. More and more communities
are developing procedural guidelines that require child protection officials
and police to conduct joint interviews and work as a team throughout child
sexual abuse investigations. 13
Sexual Offences Against Children
There are now 16 sexual offences in the Criminal Code of Canada that
could apply to child sexual abuse:
-
Sexual interference
-
Invitation to sexual touching
-
Sexual exploitation of a young person
-
Anal intercourse
-
Bestiality
-
Parent or guardian procuring sexual activity of a child
-
Householder permitting sexual activity
-
Exposing genitals to a child
-
Vagrancy
-
Offences in relation to juvenile prostitution
-
Incest
-
Corrupting children
-
Indecent acts
-
Sexual assault
-
Sexual assault with a weapon, threats to a third party or causing bodily
harm
-
Aggravated sexual assault 14
Child sexual abuse is inherently violent.
Whether or not the
abuser uses outright physical force to get
his way, the abuse
involves at the very least, interference with
and violation of,
a child's physical integrity. Women's
Research Centre
1998 Amendments To The Criminal Code
The major reforms of Bill C- 1 5 include:
- three new offences, sexual interference, sexual exploitation,
and invitation to sexual touching. These allow police to charge individuals
who have engaged children in sexual activities that lead up to but don't
necessarily include molestation or penetration
- eliminating barriers to testimony by children, in particular by eliminating
the corroboration requirement, and enacting the "ability to communicate"
test for determining the competence of children to testify in court
- permitting use of the videotape of an interview with the victim in
which the child describes the acts complained of, provided the tape is/was
made 'within a reasonable time" of the acts complained of and that the
child testifies in court
-allowing a child to testify via closed-circuit television or from behind
a screen, if this is "necessary to obtain a full and candid account" of
the acts complained of.
How Do Children Cope With Abuse?
Children who are being abused are generally powerless to stop
it by themselves. Therefore, some use denial, minimization, rationalization,
dissociation and repression as coping skills to protect themselves from
pain and take some control over their lives. These skills are critical
to their survival. Children may make attempts to shield themselves from
the abuse, hide it from others, escape the experience or call attention
to the fact that something is seriously wrong.
Blocking out or letting go of their own reality is a common way to deal
with unendurable inner turmoil. Children try to escape in many ways. Some
attempt to run away. Others numb their bodies so as not to feel what is
being done to them. Still others "leave" their bodies and watch the abuse
as if from a great distance, a form of what is called "splitting" or dissociation.
Some may retreat into fantasy or obsessive behaviour.
Children can become hyper-alert and hyper-vigilant, attuned to every
nuance in their environment in order to stay safe. Some children cry out
for help through aggressive, destructive and anti-social behaviour. They
may try to harm or mutilate themselves. This 'acting out" is often a form
of bravado used to mask fears, to conceal the abuse or to cope with the
sense of being marked or different.
The coping mechanisms of children and adolescents can turn into adult
strengths such as self-sufficiency, humour and empathy. For example, some
survivors have developed a heightened sensitivity to the pain of others
as a result of experiencing their own pain. Others have turned their capacity
to fantasize into a source of great creativity.
Unfortunately, survival skills can also become self-defeating behaviour
patterns, such as truancy, lying, stealing, abusing alcohol or drugs or
compulsive overeating. Strategies such as dissociation and numbing out
can distance survivors from their real feelings and make it harder to respond
authentically and appropriately in intimate relationships. The very skills
that enable abused children to cope can also trap them as adults, and keep
them from living the full, rich lives they deserve.
Repeated trauma in adult life erodes the structure
of the personality
already formed, but repeated trauma in childhood
form and
deforms the personality. The child trapped
in an abusive environment
is faced with formidable tasks of adaptation.
She must find a way to
preserve a sense of trust in people who are
untrustworthy, safety in
a situation that is terrifyingly unpredictable,
power in a situation of
helplessness. Judith
Herman
What Harm Does It Cause?
Child sexual abuse takes a huge toll on individuals, families
and society as a whole. Whatever form the abuse takes, the wounds left
behind can be deep and enduring. Abuse can have a wide and complex range
of effects. Some children survive sexual abuse relatively unscathed; others
are profoundly traumatized. 15
Still, survivors can and do heal. Sexual abuse is not necessarily a "ticking
time-bomb" and those who have experienced it are not destined to lives
of despair nor condemned forever to be "damaged goods."16
Some of the factors which may determine the severity of trauma include
the use of threats, force or terror, the age of the child when abuse begins,
the nature and duration of the abuse, the relationship with the abuser,
the secrecy surrounding the abuse, the clarity of the 'victim' and 'abuser'
roles, the reaction following disclosure and the nature of any subsequent
therapy 17
In the short term, victims often suffer anguish, fear, shame, betrayal,
abandonment, sadness, and a deep sense of helplessness. Sexual abuse can
interfere dramatically with the social, emotional, physical and intellectual
development of the child. Abused children may feel that they are powerless,
alone and not worthy of protection or love. Their basic worth is negated.
Establishing independence and intimacy - the tasks of early adulthood are
harder for survivors who may have problems with basic trust, autonomy and
Initiative. Their ability to form stable relationships and develop healthy
self-esteem can be seriously affected by sexual victimization in childhood.
Survivors of child sexual abuse may be more vulnerable to repeat victimization.
The risk of rape, sexual harassment, or battering, though high for all
women, is approximately doubled for survivors of abuse. 18
Contrary to popular belief, the vast majority of survivors don't abuse
or neglect their own children although the sex of the survivor has a bearing
on this. 19 While both
males and females may abuse their children, because of gender conditioning,
males are more likely to act out their pain on others and females to internalize
their suffering and hurt themselves. 20
I don't think that most people, particularly
men, have a full
appreciation of the emotional damage that
frequently happens
to sexually abused kids, or the social impact.
If they did, more
attention might be paid to preventing it.
They don't see the
suffering of the self-abuse behaviours. So
many of the men
and women in our prisons were physically and
sexually
abused. There are high levels of sexually
abused people in
our psychiatric hospitals. In alcohol, drug
abuse and
prostitution, it's the single biggest contributor.
It's a
real cost to society.
Phil Ogden, Director of Beechgrove Children's
Centre
The trauma of sexual abuse is shared by the family and community. The
family touched by incest is often torn apart and may experience shame,
degradation and financial burden. The impact on communities of both intrafamilial
and extrafamilial abuse includes heightened fear and increased demands
on already over stretched educational and social service systems. Schools
must contend with children who are experiencing the cognitive, emotional
and behavioural aftermath of abuse.
Child sexual abuse also has severe consequences for society as a whole.
It has emerged as a contributing factor underlying much adult despair,
dysfunction, addiction and criminal behaviour. The mental health system
is filled with survivors of child sexual abuse, many of whom have never
been identified as such. 21
Abuse victims seek help for eating disorders, problems with interpersonal
relationships, sexual problems, self-destructive behaviour, substance abuse,
22
suicidal feelings and dissociation disorders. Although most people who
are abused in childhood never come to psychiatric attention, many psychiatric
patients have been sexually victimized as children. 23
This has only recently been recognized by the mental health system.
Sexual abuse is also implicated in learning disabilities, prostitution,
24
and the growing numbers of youth living on the streets, 25all
of which place tremendous stress on social institutions and human services.
Taxpayers foot the enormous bill for this victimization, both in the direct
costs of protecting children, prosecuting and punishing offenders as well
as in the indirect costs of the law enforcement, correctional, social,
medical and mental health services used by victims, survivors and perpetrators.
Who Are The Perpetrators?
There is still a great deal we don't know about individuals
who sexually victimize children and what drives their behaviour. Except
for the fact that they engage children in sexual acts for their own pleasure,
child abusers are not very different from other people. There is no way
to distinguish them by race, religion, intelligence, education, occupation
or socioeconomic status. There is no one psychological profile; they are
a markedly diverse group. 26
Most sexual offenders do have one characteristic in common. The
vast majority are male. Most studies indicate that among reported perpetrators,
90% or more are men. There is also evidence pointing to the fact that a
significant minority of the male population has committed child sexual
abuse. A study conducted by Finkelhor found that 10% of the general male
population (i.e. outside correctional institutions) admitted to having
molested a child. 27
Except for the fact that they engage children
in sexual acts for
their own pleasure, child abusers are not
very different from other
people. There is no way to distinguish them
by race, religion,
intelligence, education, occupation or socioeconomic
status.
There is no one psychological profile; they
are a markedly
diverse group. Sexual offenders do have one
characteristic
in common. The vast majority are male.
One in four offenders is a member of the child's family or has been
entrusted with the child's care. Approximately half are friends or acquaintances
of the child or family. Only one in six is a stranger. 28
Therefore most victims of child sexual abuse not only deal with the trauma
of molestation but also with violation of trust. This data also calls into
question the effectiveness of warning children about "stranger danger"
as a way to prevent abuse.
Although more concern has been raised recently about adolescent sexual
offenders, we still know little about them. Roughly one-quarter of all
sexual offences are committed by youths between 12 and 17 years of age,
the vast majority of them being male. 29
The Badgley report found that almost one third of suspected or known child
sex offenders were under the age of 21. 30
Their abusive acts may be more violent and coercive than those of older
perpetrators. 31 Like
adult abusers, they are usually well known to their victims.
Some research seems to be confirming the observations of professionals
that youthful offenders are often victims of child abuse themselves. One
of the few Canadian studies on the subject shows that one-third of adolescent
offenders had experienced an abusive or neglectful childhood. 32Offender
patterns established early in life may carry on into adulthood. Early intervention
with young offenders may reduce the number of their victims and contribute
to the prevention of child sexual abuse.
The jury is still out as to the true extent of female offenders, and
a great deal of controversy and distress surrounds the issue. Most of the
research to date fails to show any significant amount of sexual abuse by
females. However, survivor reports are starting to reveal that more abuse
is perpetrated by women than previously thought. It is clear that some
women do sexually victimize children, both boys and girls. Many of them
are accomplices to men and under their control, but some are not. Some
researchers believe that abuse by females is less likely to be detected
and acknowledged because of the taboo surrounding it. As a society, we
are loath to believe that women, the "natural" nurturers of children, are
capable of such offences. As a result, survivors who have been abused by
women generally keep it to themselves, fearing hostile reactions and, at
the same time, feeling isolated and "crazy". 33
Of the child abuse offences that are reported, less than one-third of
alleged offenders are charged. Of those charged, only about a third are
convicted. Of those who are convicted, only a minority end up incarcerated
or in treatment programs. Abusers who end up in jail tend to be those who
are the most repetitive, the most disadvantaged, the most socially unattractive
and those with the least resources. 34
Studies of convicted and incarcerated offenders have shown that anywhere
from 20% to 60% had suffered physical, sexual abuse or emotional abuse
as children. While this might appear to suggest a cause of adult abusive
behaviour, it is clear that these offenders do not represent the full spectrum
of abusers. Finkelhor believes that estimates in the range of 20% to 30%
are more realistic, leaving another 70% of offenders whose abusive behaviour
can't be explained by childhood sexual trauma. 35
Most offenders are unwilling to be held accountable for their acts,
preferring to deny, minimize and rationalize their behaviour in order to
avoid recognizing the seriousness of the crimes they have committed. They
may also attempt to deflect blame onto the victim. Treatment programs have
little success in stopping abuse until offenders admit and accept responsibility
for the harm they have caused.
Of the child abuse offences that are reported,
less than one third
of alleged offenders are charged. Of those
charged, only about
one third are convicted. Of those who
are convicted, only a
minority are incarcerated or in treatment
programs. Abusers
who end up in jail tend to be those who are
the most repetitive,
the most disadvantaged, the most socially
unattractive and
those with the least resources. David
Finkelhor
The Gender Connection
Child sexual abuse must be understood within a wider social context which
promotes and condones the sexual exploitation of both women and children.
Our society is based on values which allow men to dominate women and tolerates
the misuse of power against vulnerable populations such as children. The
federal government report, Reaching for Solutions, argues that gender
inequality is an underlying cause of child sexual abuse and has a detrimental
impact on the way victims are treated. The report states:
"Social attitudes that view women and children as objects and blame
the victim who is sexually harassed or assaulted continue to be the norm
in our culture. When cases of sexual assault are before the courts, the
preoccupation often seems to be with the use of force, possible
enticement by the victim, and the moral character of the victim,
rather than on the basic responsibility and accountability of the
perpetrator for his behaviour. There is a tendency to discount the seriousness
of a perpetrator's behaviour, especially if little physical violence
is involved or the assault takes place in the family. The victims, even
children, are made to feel somehow responsible for their own victimization".
36
Many believe that male socialization lays the groundwork for their over-representation
as sexual abusers. Finkelhor suggests that males are more likely to molest
children for the following reasons:
1. Women learn earlier and much more completely to distinguish
between sexual and non-sexual forms of affection. Men are not given as
many legitimate opportunities topractise nurturing and express dependency
needs except through sex. So when men need affection and are feeling dependent,
they are much more likely to look for fulfilment in a sexual form, even
with an inappropriate partner.
2. Men grow up seeing heterosexual success as much more important
to their egos than women do. When their egos or their competencies suffer
any insult, men are much more likely than women to feel a need for sex
as a way of reconfirming their adequacy, even if the only available sexual
partner is a child.
3. Men are socialized to be able to focus their sexual interest
around sexual acts isolated from the context of a relationship. Women,
by contrast, are taught to focus on whole romantic contexts and whole relationships.
This ability of men to relate concretely to sexual acts is illustrated
in their greater interest in pornography, as well as their ability to be
aroused by children.
4. Men are socialized to see persons who are younger and smaller
than themselves as their appropriate sexual partners, while women are socialized
to see persons older and larger as their appropriate sexual partners. 37
Men do not grow up to expect they are going
to have to take care
of children. But, in addition, because they
are deprived of the
opportunity to be children at an early age,
they get alienated
from the "child within themselves". The opportunity
to identify
with children through the ability to identify
with children in
themselves is lost. We see this very
frequently with sexual
abusers. David Finkelhor
Why Don't Children Tell?
Secrecy is essential to sexual abuse. The abuser often intimidates
the child into silence. Bribes and threats may be used. Children are not
always aware that the abuse is wrong. Sometimes abusers disguise abuse
as a game, a punishment, or sex education. In some cases, a strong emotional
bond between victim and abuser leads a child to protect the perpetrator
for fear of losing affection.
Another reason for silence is shame. Abusers have ways of convincing
children that they are partners, not victims. Sometimes children feel that
they have brought on the abuse themselves, because they are "bad," or because
something is wrong with them. They may believe that telling will get them
in trouble. They may also feel guilty for enjoying the sexual activity,
being aroused by it, or allowing it to continue even though they don't
actually have the power to stop it.
Many adult survivors report that as children they desperately wanted
to be rescued from abusive situations. Unfortunately, however, when children
do try to tell adults what is happening to them they are too frequently
met with a lack of understanding, disbelief, denial or minimization. Some
children lack the words to express what is occurring and cry out for help
in other ways. 38
Silence is the greatest barrier to healing. Breaking through the secrecy
can allow the abuse to stop and the healing to begin. Children must feel
safe enough to talk about their experience and feel that they will be believed.
Sometimes, a child may reveal abuse by accident. If a child is not ready
to talk about the abuse, she or he may deny that anything happened. Time
and a great deal of reassurance may be needed before the child is ready
to provide more details. Children may make deliberate disclosures after
receiving information about child sexual abuse through programs at school
or on television.
More often, disclosures will be brought out by an adult who notices
that a child appears distressed and asks what's wrong. In these cases,
the child is often torn between wanting to tell in order to get help and
wanting to protect the offender. Disclosing abuse is often a slow process.
A child may tell the story in small pieces, testing the reactions to see
if it is safe to tell more.
Children can usually pick up cues that they are not believed, even when
an adult tells them differently. For a variety of reasons, children may
recant, or take back, their story after they tell it. This does not mean
that the child was lying. Sometimes children are pressured to deny their
story by disbelieving or hostile parents. Sometimes they seek to protect
others in the family. Sometimes the process that is set in motion after
a disclosure is so painful and upsetting that the child takes back the
story in order to bring it to an end.
Realizing what abusers do and how they do
it means we must
never excuse their actions or put their needs
above the children
they abused. We cannot blame the victim. We
cannot deny the
reality of the abuser's authority and weapons.
We must recognize
the powerlessness of children. Women's
Research Centre
What About False Allegations?
By Children
False claims of childhood sexual abuse are demonstrably rare. The consensus
of researchers is that two to eight per cent of reported cases involve
false complaints by children. 39
It is in fact far more common for children to retract true complaints because
of pressure from the perpetrator or their families. While there have been
other multi-victim cases where the accusations were put into doubt, the
Prescott case is notable for the extent of corroborating evidence for the
children's stories, and the successful prosecution of the majority of perpetrators
brought to court. In the overall tragedy of sexual abuse, false allegations
play a very small role.
By Adults
Another concern that has been given some prominence in the media is
purported false allegations by adults having recovered previously repressed
memories of childhood sexual abuse. In the United States, the False Memory
Syndrome Foundation has been created to push the idea that there is a psychological
condition where a patient is convinced by her therapist that she was a
victim of childhood sexual abuse that never happened. Foundation members
do not believe that traumatic childhood memories can be repressed for as
long as a decade or more. They believe that such memories can only be fictional
implants by unscrupulous or unprofessional therapists. They claim these
'false memories" are then genuinely taken as true by the client.
The False Memory Foundation was founded by Pamela Freyd and her husband
in reaction to alleged false accusations of sexual abuse by their daughter.
Dr. Jennifer Freyd, a professor of psychology at the University of Oregon,
has come forward recently to rebut the story promulgated by her parents
and to expose the Foundation as an organization created by a family struggling
with pain and denial, rather than a legitimate organization dedicated to
scientific memory research. The "false memory syndrome" is not medically
recognized.
As with false allegations by children, false memories by adults are
also likely to be rare. In the only recent study directly addressing this
question, it was found that out of 53 self-identified survivors of childhood
sexual abuse, 74% were able to find independent corroborative evidence.
40
Furthermore, contrary to the belief of the Foundation, partial or complete
repression of traumatic childhood memory is well-documented. In a follow-up
study of 200 adults who had been treated as children for sexual abuse,
Linda Mever Williams found that one in three did not recall the experiences
that were on their hospital records 20 years before. 41
Our justice system makes it difficult to prove
abuse, in particular
in a criminal case where the liberty of an
individual is at stake.
The fact that a person is not convicted in
a criminal proceeding
does not mean that abuse did not occur. Rix
Rogers
In 1992, the Supreme Court of Canada [in (K)M. v. (H)M.] accepted the
notion of repressed memory in ruling for the plaintiff's long-repressed
allegations of childhood sexual abuse. In view of all of the above, "false
memory syndrome" would appear to be largely a false concern. While memories
can become distorted in their details over time, traumatic memory tends
to remain true to the basic incidents, and can be trusted.
A clear distinction must be drawn between an allegation that is false
and one that is not proven in a court of law. As noted in Reachingfor
Solutions: "Our justice system makes it difficult to prove abuse, in
particular in a criminal case where the liberty of an individual is at
stake. The fact that a person is not convicted in a criminal proceeding
does not mean that abuse did not in fact occur." 42
Potential Signs Of Child Sexual Abuse
Symptoms of child sexual abuse do not follow a set pattern, nor
do all victims display the same kinds of behaviours. It is important for
parents and people working with children to be aware of the behavioural
indicators that to may indicate abuse. Because children have limited ways
to tell adults that something is wrong, some of the following could be
caused by problems other than sexual abuse. So, while the signs listed
below do not absolutely indicate that a child is being sexually abused,
they do suggest a need to find out what is disturbing the child.
In Preschoolers
-
sexualized behaviour such as preoccupation with sexual matters, and atypical
knowledge of sexual acts, exposure of genitals, seductive behaviour and
sexual victimization of other children
-
excessive rage
-
withdrawal
-
regressive behaviours such as bed-wetting, thumb-sucking and baby talk
-
fear of separation and difficulty separating from key adults
-
guilt, depression, anger and hostility, generalized anxiety and specific
fears
-
physical effects such as sleep and appetite disturbances, bruises, bleeding,
pain and itching of the genitals and problems walking or sitting
In School Age Children
In addition to the above:
-
school-related problems such as learning difficulties and declining grades,
difficulties with concentration and attention and poor peer relations
-
acting-out behaviours such as delinquency, stealing, running away and substance
abuse
-
suicide attempts and obsessions
In Adolescents
-
In addition to the above:
-
promiscuity and prostitution
-
dropping out of school and truancy 43
-
regressive or pseudomature behaviour
NOTES
1. Florence Rush's book, The Best Kept Secret:
Sexual Abuse of Children (New York: McGraw-Hill, 1980) was one of the
first to break the silence on the sexual victimization of children.
2. Rix Rogers, Reaching for Solutions.
The Report of the Special Advisor to the Minister of National Health andWelfare
on Child Sexual Abuse in Canada (Ottawa: Department of Supply and Services
Canada, 1990), p. 18.
3. David Wolfe, "The Dimensions of Multiple
Victim Child Sexual Abuse: Implications for Practice and Prevention," IPCA
Research Connection, No.1, July, 1992 (Toronto: Institute for the Prevention
of Child Abuse), p. 1.
4. Rates based on adult reports probably
underestimate the actual extent of abuse, since there are many men and
women who were victimized as children but do not remember their experiences.
5. Canadian Panel on Violence Against Women,
Changing
the Landscape: Ending Violence- Achieving Equality, ExecutiveSummary, National
Action Plan (Ottawa: Canadian Panel on Violence Against Women, 1993),
p. 11.
6. Department of Health and Welfare, Child
Sexual Abuse: Strengthening Community Response-Guidelines for Community
Workers (Ottawa: Supply and Services Canada, 1989), p. 23.
7. Wolfe, 'The Dimensions of Multiple Victim
Child Sexual Abuse,' p. 3.
8. Judith Lewis Herman, Trauma and Recovery
(New
York: Basic Books, 1992), p. 35.
9. Herman, Trauma and Recovery, p. 100.
10. Wolfe, 'The Dimensions of Multiple
Victim Child Sexual Abuse," pp. 2-3.
11. Sandy Wurtele and Cindy Miller-Perrin,
Preventing
Child Sexual Abuse: Sharing the Responsibility (Lincoln: University
of Nebraska Press, 1992), p. 14.
12. Jan Hindman, Just Before Dawn (AlexAndria
Associates, 1989), p. 10.
13. Material adapted from Put the Child
First: A Handbook About Child Abuse for Volunteers and Youth Leaders (Ottawa:
Canadian Council on Children and Youth, 1989), p. 13.
14. Mary Wells, Canada's Law on Child
Sexual Abuse (Ottawa: Department of justice Canada, 1990), p. 14.
15. A survey by Chris Bagley of 500 randomly
selected Calgary women found that 100 had been sexually victimized as children.
In an intensive study of their functioning he found that those who had
been abused were twice as likely to suffer from depression, substance abuse,
or have an episode of psychiatric hospitalization or some type of mental
health problem. A minority (20%) had acute problems. However, 50% of the
women who had been victimized were functioning very well.
16. Books such as The Courage to Heal
by
Ellen Bass and Laura Davis (New York: Harper and Row, 1988 and subsequent
editions) describe the path to healing that survivors take.
17. Jan Hindman has done extensive research
on the evaluation of trauma caused by sexual abuse. Her work questions
the validity of trauma assessment based solely on the 'Big Four' - consent,
violence, penetration and frequency - guidelines devised by the legal profession,
and concerned with determining the dangerousness of the offender, not the
suffering of the victims. Just Before Dawn provides an innovative
method of assessing trauma and planning for rehabilitation.
18. Herman, Trauma and Recovery, p.
111.
19. Herman, Trauma and Recovery, p.
114.
20. Herman, Trauma and Recovery, p.
113.
21. High rates of childhood sexual abuse
(between 73% and 90%) have been found among patients with multiple personality
disorder. Among patients with borderline personality disorder, rates vary
from 53% to 86%. Females with posttraumatic stress disorder also report
high levels of childhood sexual abuse. (From Preventing Child SexualAbuse
by
Wurtele and Miller-Perrin, p. 8.)
22. A recent study by the Addiction Research
Foundation of Ontario found that women sexually abused as children were
three times more likely than non-abused women to use medication to calm
them and twice as likely to use drugs to help them sleep. 'ARF News Release,"
August 1989, cited in Rogers, p. 84.
23. Herman, Trauma and Recovery, p.
122.
24. Childhood sexual abuse has been reported
by 52% to 73% of prostitutes. (From Preventing Child Sexual Abuse by
Wurtele and Miller-Perrin, p. 10).
25. A study done in Toronto on adolescent
runaways found that 75% of the females and 38% of the males had been sexually
abused as children. (From Adolescent Runaways: Causes and Consequences,
D.C.
Heath, 1987 by Mark-David Janus, Arlene McCormack, Ann Wolbert Burgess
and Carol Hartman, p. 27.)
26. Wurtele and Miller-Perrin, Preventing
Child Sexual Abuse, p. 16.
27. David Finkelhor, 'New Myths About Child
Sexual Abuse." An address presented at the Symposium on Child Sexual Abuse
sponsored by RIFAS." Ottawa: May @25, 1987 (Ottawa: National Clearinghouse
on Family Violence, 1989), p. 10.
28. Health and Welfare Canada, Child
Sexual Abuse: Strengthening Community Response - Guidelines for CommunityWorkers
(Ottawa:
Department of Supply and Services Canada, 1989), p. 23.
29. National Clearinghouse on Family Violence,
Adolescent
Sexual Offenders, p. 1.
30. Robin Badgley et al, Sexual Offences
Against Children and Youth (Ottawa: Department of Supply and Services
Canada, 1984), p. 847.
31. Wurtele and Miller-Perrin, Preventing
Child Sexual Abuse, p. 18.
32. National Clearinghouse on Family Violence,
Adolescent
Sexual Offenders, p. 2.
33. Michele Elliott, Female Sexual Abuse
of Children: The Ultimate Taboo (London: Longman, 1993).
34. Finkelhor, 'New Myths About Child Sexual
Abuse," pp. 6-7.
35. Finkelhor, 'New Myths About Child Sexual
Abuse,' p. 7.
36. Rogers, Reaching for Solutions,
pp.
17-18.
37. From David Finkelhor, Child Sexual
Abuse: New Theory and Research (New York. Free Press, 1984), pp. 12-13.
38. Louise Sas, Three Years After the
Verdict: A Longitudinal Study of the Social and Psychological Adjustment
of Child Witnesses Referred to the Child Witness Project (London:
London Family Court Clinic, 1993).
39. Susan Vella, 'False Memory Syndrome.
Therapists are the Targets in New Sexual Assault Defence Theory,' The National
(Canadian
Bar Association, January/February 1994), p. 37.
40. Vella, "False Memory Syndrome,' P.
37.
41. Vella, "False Memory Syndrome,' p.
37.
42. Rogers, Reaching for Solutions,
p.
79.
43. Wurtele and Miller-Perrin, Preventing
Child Sexual Abuse, pp. 103-108.
Quotes
Page l3 - Toronto Star June 9, 1991.
Page 14 - Reaching for Solutions. The Report of the Special Advisor
to the Minister of National Health and Welfareon Child Sexual Abuse in
Canada (Ottawa: Department of Supply and Services Canada, 1990), p.
18.
Page 15 -Judy Steed ,Our Little Secret: Confronting Child Sexual Abuse
in Canada (Toronto: Random House, 1994) p.xi.
Page 16 - Jan Hindman, Just Before Dawn (AlexAndria Associates,
1989), p. 10.
Page 17 - Recollecting Our Lives: Women's Experience of Childhood
Sexual Abuse (Vancouver: Press Gang, 1989),p.81.
Page 18 - Trauma and Recovery (New York: Basic Books, 1992),
p. 96.
Page 21 - "New Myths About Child Sexual Abuse" (Ottawa: National Clearinghouse
on Family Violence, 1989), pp. 6-7.
Page 22 - "New Myths About Child Sexual Abuse," p. 12.
Page 23 - Recollecting Our Lives, p. 106.
Page 24 - Reaching for Solutions, p. 79.
The Prescott Story: Background ......
|